top of page

Music and the Brain: What Learning an Instrument Really Teaches Us

Jul 10, 2023
3 min read

Updated: 20 hours ago

Learning a song gives you a useful kind of feedback: you can hear what changed. A chord starts ringing clearly. A phrase lands on the beat. Two measures that felt fine on their own finally connect. Research on music and the brain offers a way to think about what experienced musicians learn, but it doesn’t tell us that taking lessons will raise a child’s IQ or improve their grades. You don’t need those promises to make a good case for learning music.


What the Brain-Imaging Study Found


In a 2021 study published in the Journal of Neuroscience, researchers analyzed brain scans from 153 people: 52 musicians with absolute pitch, 51 musicians without it, and 50 nonmusicians. The musician groups included professionals, music students, and highly trained amateurs.

Absolute pitch is the ability to name a note without first hearing a reference note. The researchers found differences in how some brain regions were connected in musicians compared with nonmusicians. Many of those differences showed up in both musician groups, whether or not they had absolute pitch. In other words, the differences weren’t limited to people with that particular ability.


What the Study Cannot Tell Us


The researchers compared people who already had different musical backgrounds. They didn’t assign beginners to take lessons and then follow them over time. The scans can tell us where the groups differed, but they can’t tell us how much of that difference came from practice, from experiences the groups brought with them, or from other factors. The study also didn’t test whether lessons improved children’s reading, memory, or school performance.

A brain scan isn’t a progress report for an individual musician. For that, it’s more useful to look for changes you can hear and repeat.


Try This: Listen to the Join, Not the Whole Song


Imagine a beginner pianist who can play two measures correctly but pauses every time they move from one to the next. Rather than replaying the whole piece, try just the last beat of the first measure and the first beat of the next. Slow down enough to keep counting through the join. Then add a beat on either side and listen again.


Two four-beat measures with beat four of the first and beat one of the second highlighted for the practice exercise.

The point isn’t to play faster. It’s to find out whether the beat now carries through the spot where it used to stop. Recording one attempt before and after can make that change easier to hear. If the pause comes back when you add more notes, return to the smaller version. Our home piano practice guide has more ways to break a piece into manageable sections.

The same idea works away from the keyboard. A singer might start one word before an awkward entrance and listen for whether the next note arrives on time. A guitarist might practice changing between two chords without stopping the strumming hand. A teacher can help identify which part to work on and what to listen for next. See how that feedback differs in private lessons and group classes.


A Better Reason to Start Lessons


Start with something you or your child would genuinely like to play or sing. Then choose one skill that would make that music easier: a steadier beat, a clearer chord, or a smoother phrase. That gives you a better way to judge the lessons than asking whether they make someone “smarter.”

If you’re choosing for a child, our guide to online music lessons for kids explains what to look for. If you’re ready to try live instruction, here’s what to expect from a first online music lesson. You can also request a Free Session to talk through your goals and check your setup before deciding whether to try a paid lesson.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page